The Disappearance of Judge Crater

On August 6, 1930, Joseph Force Crater—a justice of the New York Supreme Court—stepped into a taxi on West 45th Street in Manhattan after dining with friends. He was never seen again. Despite one of the most intensive missing person investigations in American history, no trace of Judge Crater was ever found. He became known as “the missingest man in America.”

The Judge

Background

Joseph Force Crater was a rising star:

• Columbia Law School graduate
• Connected to Tammany Hall (New York’s Democratic political machine)
• Appointed to the New York Supreme Court in April 1930
• Age 41, married, ambitious

The Appointment

Crater’s judicial appointment came through Tammany Hall, the corrupt political organization that controlled New York City. There were later allegations that he paid $22,000 (approximately $400,000 today) for the position.

The Disappearance

August 6, 1930

Crater had returned early from a vacation in Maine:

That Evening:

• Met friends at Billy Haas’s restaurant on West 45th Street
• Seemed in good spirits
• Left the restaurant around 9:10 PM
• Hailed a taxi on the street
• Waved goodbye to his companions
• Vanished

The Delay

His wife didn’t report him missing for nine days—she assumed he was busy with work or other matters. By the time police began investigating, the trail was cold.

The Investigation

What Police Found

His Office:

• Files had been removed
• Two briefcases of documents taken
• His safe had been emptied

Financial Activity:

• He had cashed two large checks just before disappearing
• Withdrew over $5,100 (approximately $90,000 today) in cash
• Sold some stocks

His Behavior:

• He had seemed nervous to some colleagues
• Made unusual arrangements before leaving for Maine
• His truncated vacation was unexpected

What Police Never Found

• His body
• Any witness who saw him after the taxi
• The taxi driver
• A confirmed motive
• Any perpetrators
• The missing files

The Theories

Murdered by Tammany Hall

The most common theory:

• Crater knew about corruption
• A grand jury was investigating judicial appointments
• He might have been silenced before he could testify
• His missing files may have contained damaging information

Murdered by Organized Crime

• Crater associated with showgirls and nightclub figures
• He may have had gambling debts
• Connections to organized crime through Tammany were extensive
• He knew secrets that powerful people wanted kept

Started a New Life

• He withdrew large sums of money
• He may have been planning to disappear
• Perhaps he fled the coming investigation
• No evidence he surfaced elsewhere ever emerged

Suicide

• Financial or professional troubles
• Fear of exposure
• No body was found to support this

Romance Gone Wrong

• He was known to have relationships outside his marriage
• A jealous husband or associate might have killed him
• His wife destroyed some of his papers after his disappearance

The Aftermath

The Search

The Crater case became a national sensation:

• Thousands of tips investigated
• Crater “sightings” reported across the country and world
• $10,000 reward offered
• Case remained open for decades

His Wife’s Discovery

In 1939, Crater’s wife found an envelope in their apartment that she claimed to have overlooked for nine years. It contained:

• Cash
• Stocks
• A note naming people who owed Crater money
• A list of people he believed had been involved in his misfortune

The list named Tammany figures, but led nowhere.

Declared Dead

In 1939, Crater was declared legally dead. His wife collected his estate.

Cold Case

2005 Discovery

In 2005, a woman’s deathbed letter claimed her husband and others had killed Crater and buried him under the Coney Island boardwalk. Police investigated but found nothing—the area had been heavily developed since 1930.

The Reality

Judge Crater almost certainly was murdered. The circumstances—the missing files, the financial moves, the Tammany connections, the timing relative to investigations—all point to a man who knew something dangerous and was silenced.

But after 90+ years, we still don’t know what happened after he stepped into that taxi.

---

Judge Joseph Force Crater hailed a cab on West 45th Street on August 6, 1930. He climbed in, waved goodbye to his friends, and drove into oblivion. No one knows where the taxi took him. No one knows who he met. No one knows where his body lies. The missingest man in America got into a cab and never got out.